JurídicoESEN
Constitutional review ruling (C)April 2, 2009Full bench

C-260 de 2009

The official text of this ruling is in Spanish and is shown as published by the Colombian authorities.

Reporting justice Mauricio González Cuervo

✓Claimant Diogenes Escobar·Respondent Ley 100 De 1993 Artículos 152 A 289, Ley 797 De 2003 Artículo 2

✓
Topic · hard data
Fallo Inhibitorio Por Ineptitud De Demanda De Inconstitucionalidad Contra Norma De La Ley 100/93
01

Topics and subtopics of the ruling

✓What the ruling decides and analyzes, as indexed by the Court's case-law reporter's office. Each topic links to every decision that addresses it.

Inhibicion De La Corte Constitucional Por Ineptitud Sustantiva De La Demanda
  • Incumplimiento de requisitos de claridad, certeza y especificidad en los cargos
1 topic · 1 subtopic · source: case-law reporter's topic index
Case-law reporter's summary (what was argued and decided, in prose)

Norma demandada ley 797 de 2003 artículo 2 y la ley 100 de 1993 artículos 152 a 259.

El accionante formula los siguientes cargos, respecto de la ley 797, el Estado no puede obligar a todas las personas a realizar aportes a pensión y de ser obligadas se esta interfiriendo sobre su libre desarrollo de la personalidad.

En cuanto a la ley 100, argumenta que si el Estado no garantiza el derecho a la salud desconoce el derecho a la vida.

La sala observa que los argumentos que el actor expone, no son suficientes y por lo tanto no permiten decidir sobre la demanda interpuesta.

La Corte se declara inhibida para pronunciarse sobre la constitucionalidad de las normas demandadas.

Case-law reporter's text · normalized for reading (all caps → sentence case)
02

What it decided

Holdings on Ley 100/93. Hard data, verified against the operative part — citable.

Art. 13Ley 100/93 «literal a»DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 152Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 153Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 154Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 155Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 156Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 157Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 158Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 159Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 160Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 161Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 162Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 163Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 164Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 165Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 166Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 167Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 168Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 169Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 170Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 171Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 172Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 173Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 174Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 175Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 176Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 177Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 178Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 179Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 180Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 181Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 182Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 183Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 184Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 185Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 186Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 187Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 188Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 189Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 190Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 191Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 192Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 193Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 194Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 195Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 196Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 197Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 198Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 199Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 200Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 201Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 202Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 203Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 204Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 205Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 206Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 207Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 208Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 209Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 210Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 211Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 212Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 213Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 214Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 215Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 216Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 217Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 218Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 219Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 220Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 221Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 222Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 223Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 224Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 225Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 226Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 227Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 228Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 229Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 230Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 231Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 232Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 233Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 234Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 235Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 236Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 237Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 238Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 239Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 240Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 241Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 242Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 243Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 244Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 245Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 246Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 247Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 248Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 249Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 250Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 251Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 252Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 253Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 254Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 255Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 256Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 257Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 258Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 259Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 260Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 261Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 262Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 263Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 264Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 265Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 266Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 267Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 268Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 269Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 270Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 271Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 272Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 273Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 274Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 275Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 276Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 277Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 278Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 279Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 280Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 281Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 282Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 283Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 284Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 285Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 286Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 287Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 288Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
Art. 289Ley 100/93DECLINED TO RULE
139 holdings · source: operative part of the ruling
·

Operative part (Resuelve)

✓Verbatim text of the decision, as it appears in the ruling. It complements the structured holdings above.

  1. en nombre del pueblo y por mandato de la Constitucion,
  2. RESUELVE:
  3. INHIBIRSE de emitir un pronunciamiento de fondo sobre la constitucionalidad del literal a) del articulo 13 de la Ley 100 de 1993, modificado por el articulo 2o de la Ley 797 de 2003 y respecto de los articulos 152 a 289 de la Ley 100 de 1993, por ineptitud sustantiva de la demanda.
Verbatim text · source: operative part of the ruling
03

The bench that decided

We distinguish who appears in the ruling (signature, vote or concurrence) from who probably sat on the Court on that date. The difference is shown by color and shape.

Appears in the rulingN1 · hard data
✓
Mauricio González Cuervo
Reporting justice
✓
Clara Elena Reales Gutiérrez
Magistrado
✓
Cristina Pardo Schlesinger
Magistrado
✓
Gabriel Eduardo Mendoza Martelo
Magistrado
✓
Humberto Antonio Sierra Porto
Magistrado
✓
Jorge Iván Palacio Palacio
Magistrado
✓
Juan Carlos Henao Pérez
Magistrado
✓
Luis Ernesto Vargas Silva
Magistrado
✓
Nilson Pinilla Pinilla
Presidente
04

How it connects

Each decision is a node in the case-law network: it cites some and is cited by others. Follow the threads.

The document’s networkthe most influential links · node size is how often the Court cites it
← cites 17cited by 0 →C-260/09C-1052/01 — Fallo Inhibitorio Por Ineptitud De Demanda De Inconstitucionalidad Contra Norma De La Ley 617 De 2000 · cited 1,475 timesC-1052/012001C-447/97 — Dec. 1228/95. Art. 11 Parcial. Federaciones Deportivas. Demanda Materialmente Inepta. Sentencia Inhibitoria. · cited 639 timesC-447/971997C-177/01 — Genocidio Desaparicion Forzada Desplazamiento Forzado Y Tortura. Derecho Internacional Humanitario. Unidad Normativa. · cited 258 timesC-177/012001C-519/98 — Dec. 2700/91. C De P.P. Detencion Domiciliaria. Sentencia Inhibitoria Por Ausencia De Concepto De Violacion En Demanda De Inconstitucionalid · cited 229 timesC-519/981998C-362/01 — Fallo Inhibitorio Por Ineptitud De Demanda De Inconstitucionalidad Contra Norma Del Decreto 2700 De 1991 · cited 227 timesC-362/012001C-504/95 — Dec. 624/89. Art. 16 Inc. 2. Exencion De Impuestos A Las Empresas De Servicios Publicos. Juegos De Azar. Sentencia Inhibitoria. · cited 224 timesC-504/951995C-013/00 — Fallo Inhibitorio Por Ineptitud De Demanda De Inconstitucionalidad Contra Norma De La Ley 100 De 1993 · cited 220 timesC-013/002000C-281/94 — Dec. 2730/84. Dec. 80/87. Y 1787/90. Normas Sobre Transporte De Servicio Publico. Sentencia Inhibitoria. · cited 205 timesC-281/941994
constitutional review unification tutela
Cites17
C-1089/03Ley 797 De 2003.Pensiones. Art 3. Art 15 Num 1 Paragrafo 1 Primer Inciso De Ley 100 De 1993. Ingreso Base De Cotizacion No Podra Ser Inferior Al Salario Minimo Y Debera Guardar Correspondencia Con Los Ingresos Efectivamente Percibidos Por El Afiliado. ExeC-045/03Ley 599 De 2000. Art. 107 Inc. 2. Codigo Penal. Delitos Contra La Vida E Integridad Personal. Homicidio Y Homicidio Por Piedad. Induccion O Ayuda Al Suicidio. Atenuacion Punitiva. Ineptitud Sustantova De La Demanda. Inhibida.C-452/02Exceso De Facultades Extraordinarias Para Organizar Administracion Del Sistema General De Riesgos Profesionales. Regulación De Temas Para Los Cuales No Estaba FacultadoC-362/01Fallo Inhibitorio Por Ineptitud De Demanda De Inconstitucionalidad Contra Norma Del Decreto 2700 De 1991C-177/01Genocidio Desaparicion Forzada Desplazamiento Forzado Y Tortura. Derecho Internacional Humanitario. Unidad Normativa.C-1256/01Fallo Inhibitorio Por Ineptitud De Demanda De Inconstitucionalidad Contra Norma De La Ley 31 De 1992
See all 17 →
Cited by0
No decision cites it yet.

The indexed topics and subtopics of this decision are above, in Topics and subtopics of the ruling.