Constitutional review ruling (C)November 18, 1999Full bench

C-918 de 1999

The official text of this ruling is in Spanish and is shown as published by the Colombian authorities.

Reporting justice José Gregorio Hernández Galindo

✓Claimant Benjamin Ochoa Moreno Y Otro

✓

Topic · hard data

Dec.1064/99 Art.2 Lit F) 8 Inciso 3152021 Y 22. Dec.1065/99 Art. 9 Parc. Decretos Hibridos. Atribuciones Propias Del Gobierno Y Legislativas Extraordinarias. Liquidacion Caja Agraria. Inconstitucionalidad Por Consecuencia. Ley 489/98 Deja Sin Fundamento.

Topics and subtopics of the ruling

✓What the ruling decides and analyzes, as indexed by the Court's case-law reporter's office. Each topic links to every decision that addresses it.

Caja Agraria

Liquidación

Inconstitucionalidad Por Consecuencia

Decreto Hibrido

Dificultad para control constitucional
Inexistencia

3 topics · 3 subtopics · source: case-law reporter's topic index

What it decided

Holdings on Decreto 1064/99. Hard data, verified against the operative part — citable.

Art. 15Decreto 1064/99STRUCK DOWN

Art. 2Decreto 1064/99STRUCK DOWN

Art. 20Decreto 1064/99STRUCK DOWN

Art. 21Decreto 1064/99STRUCK DOWN

Art. 22Decreto 1064/99STRUCK DOWN

Art. 8Decreto 1064/99STRUCK DOWN

Art. 9Decreto 1065/99STRUCK DOWN

7 holdings · source: operative part of the ruling

Operative part (Resuelve)

✓Verbatim text of the decision, as it appears in the ruling. It complements the structured holdings above.

en nombre del pueblo y por mandato de la Constitución,
RESUELVE:
Decláranse INEXEQUIBLES en su totalidad, a partir de la fecha de su promulgación, los decretos leyes 1064 y 1065 de 1999.

Verbatim text · source: operative part of the ruling

The bench that decided

We distinguish who appears in the ruling (signature, vote or concurrence) from who probably sat on the Court on that date. The difference is shown by color and shape.

Appears in the rulingN1 · hard data

✓

José Gregorio Hernández Galindo

Reporting justice

✓

Alejandro Martínez Caballero

Presidente

✓

Alfredo Beltrán Sierra

Antonio Barrera Carbonell

✓

Vladimiro Naranjo Mesa

Magistrado

Read dissent

Separate opinions — text available2

DissentEduardo Cifuentes Muñoz DissentVladimiro Naranjo Mesa

Official text from the case-law reporter · the most valuable part of the ruling: the positions that did not carry the majority.

How it connects

Each decision is a node in the case-law network: it cites some and is cited by others. Follow the threads.

The document’s networkthe most influential links · node size is how often the Court cites it

constitutional review unification tutela

Cites1

C-702/99Ley 489/98. Arts. 738475968 Y 111 Parciales Y; 5152535455 Y 120. Reestructuracion Del Estado. Facultades Extraordinarias Del Presidente. Exequibles E Inexequibles.

Cited by7

T-474/01Derecho De Asociacion Sindical. Supresion De Cargos De Personas Afiliadas A Sindicato Por Reestructuracion. Legitimacion Por Activa De Sindicato. Despidos Colectivos. Reduccion De Personal En Entidades Donde Tenga Participacion El Estado. Negada.A. 256/01Solicitud Nulidad Sentencia T-474/01 T-1366/00Derecho Al Trabajo. Solicitud Reintegro. Pago Acreencias Laborales. Despido Masivo. Caja Agraria. Negada.SU.879/00Derecho De Peticion Y Trabajo. Terminacion De La Relacion Laboral Con La Caja Agraria. Reintegros. Pagos De Prestaciones. Reapertura De Guarderia. Concedida Parcialmente.C-644/00Fallo Inhibitorio Por Falta De Competencia De La Corte Constitucional C-969/99Decs.10641122112311311132113411351136113911421144114511461147114911531154115511561157115811591160116111621163116411651166 11671168116911701178117911801181 Y 1184/99 Inconstitucionalidad Por Consecuencia Ver <a Href=../1999/C-702-99.Rtf> C-702/99</A>.

See all 7 →

The indexed topics and subtopics of this decision are above, in Topics and subtopics of the ruling.